[1]卢贤英,高静,柏丁兮,等.15种补充和替代医学疗法缓解新生儿足跟采血疼痛的网状Meta分析[J].军事护理,2023,40(01):77-83.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.2097-1826.2023.01.019]
　LU Xianying,GAO Jing,BAI Dingxi,et al.15 Complementary and Alternative Medicines in Relieving Pain of Newborn Caused by Heel Blood Collection:A Network Meta-Analysis[J].Nursing Journal Of Chinese People's Laberation Army,2023,40(01):77-83.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.2097-1826.2023.01.019]
点击复制

15种补充和替代医学疗法缓解新生儿足跟采血疼痛的网状Meta分析
分享到：

《军事护理》[ISSN:2097-1826/CN:31-3186/R]

卷:
40
期数:
2023年01期
页码:
77-83
栏目:
循证护理
出版日期:
2023-01-15

文章信息/Info

Title:
15 Complementary and Alternative Medicines in Relieving Pain of Newborn Caused by Heel Blood Collection:A Network Meta-Analysis
文章编号:
2097-1826(2023)01-0077-07
作者:
卢贤英; 高静; 柏丁兮; 刘锐芮; 王薇; 蔡明瑾
(成都中医药大学 护理学院, 四川 成都 610075)
Author(s):
LU Xianying; GAO Jing; BAI Dingxi; LIU Ruirui; WANG Wei; CAI Mingjin
(School of Nursing,Chengdu University of Traditional Chinese Medicine,Chengdu 610075,Sichuan Province,China)
关键词:
补充替代医学疗法;  新生儿;  足跟采血;  疼痛;  网状Meta分析
Keywords:
CAM;  newborn;  heel blood collection;  pain;  network meta-analysis
分类号:
R473.72
DOI:
10.3969/j.issn.2097-1826.2023.01.019
文献标志码:
A
摘要:
目的 评价不同补充和替代医学(complementary and alternative medicine,CAM)疗法对缓解新生儿足跟采血疼痛的应用效果。方法 计算机检索PubMed、Embase、Web of Science、Cochrane、CINAHL、中国知网、维普、万方、中国生物医学文献数据库,时限为建库至2022年2月。采用Cochrane 5.1.0手册进行质量评价,Stata 15.0进行频率学网状Meta分析。结果 共纳入44篇随机对照试验(足月儿29篇、早产儿15篇),涉及15种CAM(足月儿14种、早产儿7种),5206例新生儿(足月儿4337例、早产儿869例)。研究显示:对足月儿,12种CAM缓解疼痛的效果均优于常规干预(均P<0.05),母乳吮吸的汇总累积排序概率图下面积(surface under the cumulative,SUCRA)最大; 对早产儿,5种CAM缓解疼痛的效果均优于常规干预(均P<0.05),音乐+非营养性吮吸(non-nutritive sucking,NNS)的SUCRA最大。结论 母乳吮吸缓解足月儿疼痛效果最佳,音乐+NNS缓解早产儿疼痛效果最佳; 此外,音乐联合干预效果比音乐单独干预更佳; 研究结果对临床护理人员干预新生儿疼痛具有指导意义。
Abstract:
Objective To evaluate the effect of various complementary and alternative medicines(CAM)on relieving the pain of newborns caused by heel blood collection.Methods The databases of PubMed,Embase,Web of Science,Cochrane,CINAHL,CNKI,VIP,Wanfang,and CBM were searched from the inception up to February 2022.The Cochrane 5.1.0 Handbook was used to assess the quality of the included studies.Stata15.0 software was used for frequency reticulation meta-analysis.Results A total of 44 randomized controlled trials(29 for term-infants and 15 for preterm-infants)were included,involving 15 CAM(14 term-infants and 7 premature-infants),with a total of 5206 patients(4337 term infants and 869 preterm infants).For full-term infants,12 CAM on pain relief were better than conventional intervention(all P<0.05),and surface under the cumulative(SUCRA)of breast-feeding was the largest.For premature infants,5 CAM were superior to conventional interventions(all P<0.05),and SUCRA of music and non-nutritive sucking(NNS)was the largest.Conclusions Breast-feeding is the best way to relieve pain in full-term infants,and music and NNS are the best way to relieve pain in premature infants.Moreover,the combined music intervention is more effective than the music alone.It has guiding significance for nursing staff to intervene in neonatal pain.

参考文献/References:

[1] 林紫,郑显兰,沈巧,等.儿童疼痛评估的研究进展[J].全科护理,2019,17(25):3098-3101.
[2] LAGO P,GARETTI E,BOCCUZZO G,et al.Procedural pain in neonates:the state of the art in the implementation of national guidelines in Italy[J].Paediatr Anaesth,2013,23(5):407-414.
[3] 邹潇璐,牟晓文,刘红红.袋鼠式护理对足月新生儿疼痛、摄入量及母乳喂养率的影响分析[J].现代医学与健康研究电子杂志,2017,1(8):92-93.
[4] 张亚琼.袋鼠式护理对新生儿疼痛、生长发育及母乳喂养的影响[J].护理研究,2020,20(11):254-255.
[5] 万静,游勇.袋鼠式护理对母乳喂养、新生儿神经行为及新生儿疼痛的影响[J].广西医学,2018,40(13):1514-1517.
[6] 张小凤,陶懿.非营养性吸吮对新生儿足跟采血疼痛的影响探讨[J].医药前沿,2020,10(4):170-171.
[7] TANJU O,FATMA Y K.Effect of acupressure on procedural pain before heel lancing in neonates[J].J Tradit Chin Med,2021,41(2):331-337.
[8] 刘文静,李鸿洁,高雅娜,等.抚触对采集足跟血时新生儿生命体征的影响[J].饮食保健,2020,7(7):131-132.
[9] 李雪芬,应静君.抚触缓解足跟采血所致新生儿疼痛的研究[J].中国新生儿科杂志,2012,27(2):115-116.
[10]黄凌雁,张伟青,彭晓云,等.婴儿抚触对缓解新生儿足跟采血所致疼痛的效果观察[J].中华现代护理杂志,2010,16(8):877-878.
[11]王翠萍,邵青春,李玉华,等.俯卧位对足跟采血所致新生儿疼痛反应的影响[J].齐鲁护理杂志,2010,16(2):45.
[12]赵晓红,张贺珍.袋鼠式护理对足月新生儿足跟采血所致疼痛的影响[J].大家健康:中旬版,2016,10(11):182-183.
[13]王建华,何川.襁褓法对新生儿足跟采血疼痛管理的疗效分析[J].健康必读,2020,(1):66-67.
[14]刘金双,王凤,杨海云.探讨包布包裹和手环抱法对采足跟血新生儿疼痛的影响[J].护理实践与研究,2010,7(18):97-98.
[15]ERKUT Z,YILDIZ S.The effect of swaddling on pain,vital signs,and crying duration during heel lance in newborns[J].Pain Manag Nurs,2017,18(5):328-336.
[16]雷菊芳.袋鼠式护理护理联合音乐疗法对新生儿足跟采血疼痛的影响[J].健康之路,2018,17(1):147.
[17]李华.母乳喂养联合音乐疗法缓解新生儿足跟采血疼痛的效果观察[J].国际护理学杂志,2015,34(16):2177-2179.
[18]WU H,ZHANG J,DING Q,et al.Effect analysis of embracing breast milk sucking to relieve pain of neonatal heel blood sampling:a randomized controlled trial[J].Ann Palliat Med,2021,10(4):4384-4390.
[19]朱美艳.不同护理干预措施缓解新生儿足底采血疼痛的效果[J].中国实用医药,2018,13(8):192-193.
[20]YILMAZ F,ARIKAN D.The effects of various interventions to newborns on pain and duration of crying[J].J Clin Nurs,2010,20(7-8):1008-1017.
[21]卢慧,李蓉,马学华.非营养性吸吮与口服25%葡萄糖溶液对缓解新生儿足跟采血疼痛的比较研究[J].空军医学杂志,2017,33(3):210-212.
[22]张伟青,黄凌雁,张舒梅,等.抚触和非营养性吸吮对新生儿足跟采血时疼痛程度的影响研究[J].护理实践与研究,2011,8(11):19-21.
[23]黄月爱,黄艳琼.口服蔗糖联合音乐疗法对新生儿足跟采血疼痛的影响[J].中国卫生标准管理,2020,11(14):61-65.
[24]ZHU J,HONG G H,ZHOU X,et al.Pain relief effect of breast feeding and music therapy during heel lance for healthy-term neonates in China:a randomized controlled trial[J].Midwifery,2015,31(3):365-372.
[25]姚海娟,孙斌,缪珀,等.新生儿疼痛的干预方法和止痛措施的临床效果研究[J].中国血液流变学杂志,2013,23(1):132-134.
[26]张洁,张齐放.不同干预方法对缓解新生儿足底采血疼痛的研究[J].护理研究,2013,27(32):3651-3652.
[27]SOLTANI S,ZOHOORI D,ADINEH M.Comparison the effectiveness of breastfeeding,oral 25% dextrose,kangaroo-mother care method,and EMLA cream on pain score level following heal pick sampling in newborns:a randomized clinical trial[J].Electron Physician,2018,10(5):6741-6748.
[28]徐承红.非营养性吸吮护理在新生儿足底血疼痛缓解中的作用[J].家有孕宝,2021, 3(3): 41.
[29]魏晓铭,黄庆琴,张文娟,等.拥抱抚触、非营养性吸吮联合干预对新生儿足底采血时心率和疼痛的影响[J].中国医药科学,2017,7(18):71-73.
[30]练森勤,李秋红.袋鼠式护理结合足底按摩对新生儿足跟采血疼痛的影响[J].名医,2021(7):153-154.
[31]本乐乐,张媛媛,杨巧芳.“袋鼠妈妈”式护理联合音乐疗法对新生儿足跟采血疼痛的影响[J].当代护士:下旬刊,2015(1):75-76.
[32]WANG Y,ZHANG L,DONG W,et al.Effects of kangaroo mother care on repeated procedural pain and cerebral oxygenation in preterm infants[J/OL].(2021-06-30).https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34192768/.DOI:10.1055/5-0041-731650.
[33]JOHNS C C,FILION F,CAMPBELL Y M,et al.Kangaroo mother care diminishes pain from heel lance in very preterm neonates:a crossover trial[J/OL].(2008-04-24).https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18435837/.DOI:10.1186/1471-2431-8-13.
[34]NIMBALKAR S M,CHAUDHARY N S,GADHAVI K V,et al.Kangaroo mother care in reducing pain in preterm neonates on heel prick[J].Indian J Pediatr,2013,80(1):6-10.
[35]杨文美,吴梅秀.非营养性吸吮对缓解早产儿操作性疼痛的影响[J].当代护士:中旬刊,2016(2):50-51.
[36]张映旭,陈敬国,夏荣华,等.早产儿足跟采血疼痛评估及非营养性吸吮对疼痛的影响[J].护理实践与研究,2010,7(2):26-27.
[37]SANDEEP R,ANIRUDH G,TARSEM J.Twenty-five percent dextrose and EBM in pain relief during heel lance in late preterm babies using the PIPP score:a randomized controlled trial[J].J Neonatol,2018,32(2-3):43-49.
[38]鲁琦,汪丽平,张海玲,等.舌尖滴入微量24%蔗糖水对早产儿足跟采血疼痛反应的影响[J].护理研究,2011,25(34):3143-3144.
[39]CRISTINA C,ANNA C,GAETANO D M,et al.Effect of mozart music on heel prick pain in preterm infants:a pilot randomized controlled trial[J].J Pediatr Neonatal Individ Med,2015,4(1):40109-40114.
[40]罗金,尹宏智,黄燕芳,等.角音干预早产儿足跟采血疼痛临床研究[J].新中医,2019,51(8):295-297.
[41]SILVEIRA A,CHRISTOFFEL M M,VELARDE L G,et al.Effect of glucose and non-nutritive sucking on puncture pain in premature infants:a crossover clinical trial[J/OL].(2021-05-26).https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34076179/.DOI:10.15901S1980-220X2020018303732.
[42]SEN E,MANAV G.Effect of kangaroo care and oral sucrose on pain in premature infants:a randomized controlled trial[J].Pain Manag Nurs,2020,21(6):556-564.
[43]贺芳,刘会,曹蕾,等.非营养性吸吮与口服葡萄糖对早产儿足跟采血疼痛的影响[J].护理学杂志,2020,35(13):16-18.
[44]UEMATSU H,SOBUE I.Effect of music and non-nutritive sucking on heel lance in preterm infants:a randomized controlled crossover trial[J].Paediatr Child Health,2019,24(1):33-39.
[45]GAO H,LI M,Gao H,et al.Effect of non-nutritive sucking and sucrose alone and in combination for repeated procedural pain in preterm infants:a randomized controlled trial[J].Int J Nurs Stud,2018(83):25-33.
[46]SHAH S R,KADAGE S,SINN J.Trial of music,sucrose,and combination therapy for pain relief during heel prick procedures in neonates[J].J Pediatr,2017(190):153-158.
[47]LOCATELLI C,BELLIENI C V.Sensorial saturation and neonatal pain:a review[J].J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med,2017,31(23):3209-3213.
[48]刘丽香,莫蓓蓉,雷佳芳.袋鼠式护理缓解足跟采血所致新生儿疼痛的Meta分析[J].护理实践与研究,2017,14(19):7-11.
[49]POLKKI T,KORHONEN A,LAUKKALA H.Parents' use of nonpharmacologic methods to manage procedural pain in infants[J].J Obstet Gynecol Neonatal Nurs,2018,47(1):43-51.

相似文献/References:

[1]邵梦烨,罗培培,秦秀群,等.新生儿吸吮功能评估工具的研究进展[J].军事护理,2022,39(07):17.[doi:10.3969/j.issn.2097-1826.2022.07.005]

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:
【 收稿日期 】 20022-03-10 【 修回日期 】 2022-12-15
【 基金项目 】 成都中医药大学“杏林学者”学科人才科研提升计划(编号:MPRC2021021)、2022年四川省心理健康教育研究中心项目(编号:XLJKJY2203A)
【 作者简介 】 卢贤英,硕士在读,护士,电话:028-61800154
【 通信作者 】 高静,电话:028-61800154
更新日期/Last Update: 2023-01-15